I experienced President Obama render a armed forces salute when honoring KIAs in ~ Dover AFB. The is a civilian in civilian clothes. He is no a veteran. Is he licensed has been granted to render the salute or is his ideal sign of respect a hand end his heart?Editor: terrific question, John.

You are watching: Is the president required to salute

We suspect plenty of Americans may also be wondering v you if a presidential salute is authorized in this, or any other, setting. There was fairly a little bit of publicity complying with Obama"s appearance at Dover AFB, Delaware, to pay his respects as the continues to be of fallen company members and also DEA agents killed in Afghanistan were returned to the united States.Many doubters roundly criticize Obama, who practically immediately after acquisition office in 2009 lifted the half on photographing the return the fallen company members. Was he really paying his respects? Or was he just exploiting these soldiers who offered the ultimate sacrifice by grabbing a photo opp - maybe hoping come deflect several of the criticism stemming native his hold-up in deciding top top a request by Gen. Stanley McChrystal come send an ext troops come Afghanistan?Now-famous picture of Obama top top the presidential project trail failing to location his hand over his heart (and instead offering his "crotch salute") throughout the power of the national anthem add fuel to the firestorm that criticism.
*
According to FoxNews.com, president Ronald Reagan began the exercise of saluting members the our armed forces in 1981. Such salutes are normally not calculation by one not in uniform, even active duty business members. No American president before Reagan had ever before returned a salute, including previous five-star army General Dwight D. Eisenhower. Customarily, one officer in uniform does not salute enlisted personnel or officers of lower rank.The military salute is a authorize of respect, rendered to one senior in rank, i beg your pardon is then reverted by the senior as a authorize of shared respect.The president traditionally is briefed on suitable military protocol through the White house military office, i m sorry is staffed by members of each service. However according to Nancy Brinker, chairman George W. Bush"s former chief of protocol, the president normally makes decisions around how he desire to conduct business, and also some custom-mades can it is in altered.President Obama broke from armed forces protocol early on in his presidency by extending his hand come shake the of one enlisted maritime standing in salute in ~ the base of the measures to naval One, the president"s helicopter. The startled maritime shook the president"s hand, and also then resumed his salute.
*
President Obama startles saluting marine by getting to out to shake his hand in this FOX News Channel photo.Federal statutes specifying flag protocol limited the best to salute the flag to those at this time serving or veterans who have actually previously served in the military, as soon as in uniform. That legislation was amended in 2008 to allow veterans to render armed forces salutes to the flag even when no in uniform.The only exception is the sitting president, because he is additionally Commander-in-Chief of our nation"s military.Only two presidents in recent history have never ever served in the armed forces - Barack Obama and also Bill Clinton, both Democrats. Every other American president due to the fact that the finish of human being War II has actually served in our military throughout times of war: bother Truman, COL, USAR; Dwight D. Eisenhower, general of the Army, USA (who was can be fried Allied commander in people War II); man F. Kennedy, LT, USN;Lyndon Johnson, CDR, USNR; Richard Nixon, CDR, USNR; Jimmy Carter, LT, USN; Ronald Reagan, CPT, USAR, USAAC; George H.W. Bush, LT, USN; and also George W. Bush, 1LT, Texas Air nationwide Guard. So John, the quick answer to your question is yes, through virtue the his place as Commander-in-Chief (which is questioned by many), Barack Obama is authorized come render a presidential salute in this situation.


Comments for Presidential Salute

mean Rating

Click right here to add your very own comments


Rating
Respect because that President Obama by: Mrs. Foster i am saddened to review the contempt that so countless of you have for president Obama. You complain that he disrespects the veterans, yet you in turn are insolent toward the leader the the complimentary world. As Americans, we have to support ours leaders. Even if girlfriend don"t favor the man, we have a duty to "respect the office." Trying to embarrass our leader because he must or must not salute is no what the discussion should be. These are perilous times folks. In March, North korean Supreme Leader, Kim Jong-Un posed near a atom warhead. Currently that, people, is a topic for discussion. God bless America.Mrs. Foster, permit me watch if i can assist you recognize the contempt the President Obama has earned amongst veterans and also military families, that have an individual "skin in the game." You say we should respect our leaders. That"s part of the trouble - he"s not a leader. He"s one organizer. He began his presidency v an apology tour, apologizing around the human being for America and bowing to foreign leaders. He doesn"t respect the office himself, for this reason how deserve to we respect that in it?Many of our soldiers, sailors, airmen and also marines died or suffered catastrophic injuries in the campaign to liberate Iraq. Climate Obama bring away office, announces precisely the day he will withdraw troops, and also does so, leaving a vacuum the was easily filled through ISIS. No armed forces tactician will certainly tell girlfriend it"s a an excellent idea to telegraph her next move to her adversary. That doesn"t respect his duty to acknowledge the sacrifice that has been made by our troops when he hands that hard-won territory ago to a federal government he knows is as well weak to protect it, and creates a vacuum conveniently filled by ISIS.Maybe friend don"t gain it, but Americans have already fought, bled and also died to defend that ground and also its people, and our president, by his inept policies, has actually in significance handed it back to the terrorists.Our military has a history, due to the fact that its inception, the leaving nobody behind, or there is no support. Yet, when American diplomats were under assault in Libya, he and his secretary of state (Mrs. Clinton) not just did nothing come send aid, they further gave stand down orders to troops the were poised and also ready to walk render aid. American diplomats and also veterans died, unnecessarily, since the president turned a remote eye and refused to send help, and then he and also Mrs. Clinton ongoing to perpetuate a lie about the reason of the attack. The was right there together Mrs. Clinton looked into the encounters of their ruined families and also lied to them about that. How have the right to we respect the or what he has turned the office into?Then he renders a address Iran that assures the biggest state sponsor of terror will eventually have atom weapons, which endangers every American. And pays "ransom" for the release of Americans, which simply put a price ~ above the head that every American overseas, including particularly our troops. America began its plan of not paying ransom under President cutting board Jefferson. To who did the refuse to pay ransom? The Muslim Barbary Pirates, that were terrorizing shipping in the Mediterranean and also parts the the eastern Atlantic. Castle routinely recorded ships and sold the crews into slavery. Mr. Jefferson decided it to be time to placed an finish to your bullying of ships on the sea, and sent ours Marines to take care of the problem.That"s why the Marines" "fight song," beginning out, "From the halls the Montezuma come THE SHORES that TRIPOLI ...." most Americans have actually no idea what that referral means, but it describes our Marines defeating Muslim terrorism more than 200 year ago. And also our Marines could easily loss them again, if Mr. Obama and also his team would untie their appropriate hands and also let them carry out their jobs.By the way, that"s additionally where the ax "Barbarian" originates, due to the fact that the Mohammedans (as they were dubbed then) were so cruel. In fact, the Marine got their nickname the "leathernecks" due to the fact that of the leather band they wore about their necks come thwart Muslim terrorists who were trying to behead them. Today"s Muslim terrorists space still trying come behead everyone who does not believe as they do, and Mr. Obama stops working to carry out what is crucial to safeguard Americans and the remainder of the world.Obama and his administration have done an ext damage to America 보다 all our previous opponents combined. He has developed policy after plan that it seems to be ~ to united state decidedly "un-American." and also despite declare to it is in a Christian, he states nothing around the persecution and beheading that Christians, and also promotes to teach Islam in our schools as soon as not only is Christianity not enabled to be taught, but Christians are not even allowed to pray there.There"s so much more, yet I simply don"t have time to list all the ways Obama has actually betrayed America. Ns hope that helps to offer you an inkling why Obama is hosted in contempt by lot of the military and also veteran population.Anyone else care to add their comment to aid Mrs. Foster understand?

Rating
Commander and chief? by: cotton If that is the Commander and also Chief, does that no make him the greatest ranking officer?Actually, through law, the country highest-ranking military officer is the Chairman that the joint Chiefs of Staff. In this capacity, he serves as the principal armed forces adviser to the President, the Secretary of Defense and the nationwide Security Council.

Rating
TV protocol by: Steve i noticed in the recent Chattanooga assault that Obama was sitting as soon as he make his brief speech. Is there a protocol because that the chairman to be at least "standing" as soon as speaking around slain soldiers?Not that we"re aware of, Steve. Perhaps if there"s a reader that knows of one, they"ll let united state know. Thanks for your question.

Rating
Presidential Salute by: LTC (Ret) Richard Cardillo ns am dismayed (and have written the White house on several occasions) on how the President, watch reluctantly, return the salute the the naval guard at the foot that the Presidential Helicopter. Due to the fact that my beforehand days together a Lieutenant, ns was schooled to constantly render a cheery word to the one saluting me as a sign of acknowledgment that our mutual responsibility to the traditions of the military. The is not of authorize of subservience but a greeting between men of arms. The president have to smile and say something familiar to that soldier or Marine. The does not. I wish the would, instead of wade silently as if he is embarrassed to be command in Chief.Rich CardilloThank you, sir, for her service.I have actually an idea the reluctant salute come which girlfriend object might be the an outcome of briefings through the President"s protocol officers following the event in which the was thought about "overly friendly" v the maritime guard by reaching out come shake the young man"s hand when he rendered his salute come the president (photo above).As you mention, if the chairman is uncomfortable returning the salute, the could constantly say a trusted word and smile or nod his head in acknowledgment that the salute.

Rating
Salute by: cotton You mention the hand over the heart throughout the national Anthem.I"ve never done this. The hand over her heart is because that the Pledge of Allegiance. You stand for the national Anthem. Title 36, United claims Code, chapter 10, ar 171 mentions the suitable conduct during playing the the nationwide Anthem:"During rendition of the nationwide anthem when the flag is displayed, all present except those in uniform must stand at attention facing the flag v the appropriate hand end the heart.

See more: Is Pedialyte Good For Stomach Flu, Nutrition For The Stomach Flu

Men no in uniform should remove their headdress through their ideal hand and also hold it in ~ the left shoulder, the hand being end the heart. People in uniform need to render the armed forces salute in ~ the an initial note that the anthem and also retain this position until the last note. When the flag is not displayed, those existing should confront toward the music and act in the very same manner they would certainly if the flag were displayed there."

Rating
The president Should collection an Example by: Mike, Danville, IL ns have listed that chairman Obama does neither option yet has his hands folded at his crotch.As command in chief, he most likely should observe some kind of respect because that our nation"s flag.Mike, we agree. If you"ll notice, it appears that his advisers have persuaded Obama that his lack of respect for our nation"s signs - the flag, the nationwide anthem, etc. - rankles countless Americans. If girlfriend watched his appearance in ~ the memorial service in Tucson honoring the victim of the fixed shooting the injured Congresswoman Gabby Giffords, friend may have actually noticed that he put his hand end his heart throughout the playing of the national anthem, and also I believe he was additionally wearing a flag lapel pin, i beg your pardon he originally refused to do.So supposedly he"s respecting (or at the very least pretending to respect) the wishes of the countless us that were offended by his lack of respect for our country"s background and its symbols.It seems to it is in a pretty clean (but unfortunately no rare) example of a politician going versus his own ethics in an attempt to get re-elected.

Rating
OK... by: cotton I"m a previous unit level command in the ARMY. Though I"m no an Obama supporter, the place of the POTUS is come be respect by armed forces personnel even if it is or not the human being in the position has earned the respect. (This walk for any president or ranking official). Ns am grateful that Obama has actually been coached through his military staff and also advisors and returns the respect presented by soldiers and also to the flag. The soldiers and the flag have earned the right... Now: regarding hugging the Medal of honor recipient? that was unprofessional. From the soldier"s wife or Michelle Obama? No problem. But from a an elderly individual, it implies familiarity and favoritism. The handshake to be appropriate and sufficient.

Rating
Saluting and Commander In Chief by: cotton "Customarily, one in uniform does not salute enlisted personnel or officers of lower rank."Huh, This makes no sense to me.Federalist #69:To depicted Alexander Hamilton, the chairman is no Commander In chief UNTIL called into actual service by Congress, i.e., a statements of War.No explanation of War has been made due to the fact that WWII and yes over there is a big difference in between Declaring War and also authorizing the chairman to fairy war(which incidentally is not uncovered as a power or a method in the Constitution.We"ll tackle your 2 points in order.In the U.S. Military, personnel in uniform are compelled to render a salute once they meet and also recognize persons entitled (by grade) come a salute, except when inappropriate or impractical . . . .Those licensed has been granted to a salute (by grade):President the the United says (Commander-in-Chief)Commissioned OfficersWarrant OfficersAny Medal of honor recipientOfficers the friendly international countriesArmy Regulation 600-20; military Command Policy, paragraph 4-9 reads:"The salute is extensively misunderstood external the military. Some think about it to be a gesture the servility since the junior extends a salute come the senior, but we know that the is rather the opposite. The salute is an expression the recognizes each various other as a member the the job of arms; that they have actually made a an individual commitment the self-sacrifice to keep our means of life. The truth that the junior extends the greeting very first is simply a point of etiquette -- a salute prolonged or returned renders the exact same statement."The quote you referenced over simply recognizes that enlisted personnel perform not salute every other, also when one is an elderly to the other; and also that that is the small of the two members that initiates the salute (therefore policemans do no initiate a salute with one more officer of lower rank). It would have been clearer had it stated one "does not initiate a salute . . ."Now does it make sense?With regard to Federalist #69, among the Federalist papers authored by Alexander Hamilton, we see just how you can have attracted that conclusion, however that"s no what it actually says. The relevant section says:"The president is to it is in the "commander-in-chief of the army and navy the the joined States, and of the militia of the numerous States, when dubbed into the actual organization of the united States....""This is an excellent example that why proper word placement, phrasing and also punctuation is crucial to convey the meaning of the written word. The 2nd comma shouldn"t it is in there, and also rewording could have do the an interpretation more clear. What this passage method is the the chairman is always the commander-in-chief that the army and also navy, and also when the state militias are referred to as into the actual company of the United claims (federalized), the becomes your commander-in-chief also during the time they space in commonwealth service.I expect this helps to clarify these two concerns for you.

Rating
The right to Salute is Earned by: Brenda, Lake City, FL The Salute is something earn in the military. It have to not be something for someone together a president to "change", this have to not be his/her right. It yes, really is mental every time I see him saluting while not under cover, and also he has actually never served in the military. The is nothing an ext than a DOD employee that will be the end of office in 4 years. If the really wants to respect the military, climate he can stop saluting!

Rating
Presidential Salute by: Carl prefer it or not, Mr. Obama is commander in Chief and can nice well do as he pleases. Mine salute to Sen. Inhofe!

Rating
Disrespect in the Military by: cotton these comments have been relocated to our discussion of Barack Obama"s eligibility to be President.

Click below to include your own comments

sign up with in and write your own page! It"s basic to do. How? merely click right here to return to concerns or Comments around Saluting the Flag?.


Site Info

Money Matters

Debt Matters

Credit Matters

Tax Matters

Family Matters

Support our Troops

Honor their Service

Political Matters

Your Comment Matters

Resources

Admin Matters