Dayne Walling Flipped the switch That collection Off the Flint Water Crisis. Now, he’s Trying to make a Comeback.

You are watching: Is the mayor of flint michigan a democrat

Edward McClelland is author of Young Mr. Obama: Chicago and the do of a black President and How come Speak Midwestern.

Dayne Walling was mayor of Flint, Michigan, for six years, yet he is ideal remembered for a solitary day. ~ above April 25, 2014, as news cameras rolled, Walling propelled the button that shut off the city’s link to Detroit’s water system and switched it come the Flint River. Return Walling had not made the decision to draw water from the Flint River—that was decided by one emergency manager appointed through the state to usurp his mayoral powers—he enforcement the physical act the initiated the Flint water crisis. As soon as the switch to be complete, the hoisted a glass of river water, toasting “Here’s to Flint!”

The water, the course, was found to it is in tainted through lead, as a an outcome of engineers’ fail to treat it through corrosion controls. Hundreds of kids have since been diagnosed v lead poisoning, and also a dozen Flint residents passed away of Legionella from drinking flow water. Walling never ever lived under that moment. Nor did that live down a morning TV appearance during which the drank a mug the Flint water and declared, “My family and also I drink the water every day. … all of our tests, ever because this year, have actually been similar with what we provided to acquire out the Detroit.”

In the fall of 2015, once a local doctor presented evidence that Flint’s children had elevated level of lead in their blood, Walling scrambled come reconnect his city’s water supply to Detroit. However the damages to Flint’s residents, and his own reputation, was done. The November, angry Flintstones voted Walling the end of office, making the the first political accident of the water crisis.

But virtually four years after that election, Dayne Walling is do the efforts to make a comeback, through a bid to stand for the southwest edge of Flint and three that its suburbs in the Michigan house of Representatives. The is facing off against five opponents in the august 7 autonomous primary, and while over there hasn’t been any type of polling in the race, Walling is considered an underdog. That still has name recognition and goodwill left over from his time as mayor, however he additionally faces the skepticism and also anger that voters who felt he no do sufficient to stop the greatest disaster in his city’s history. Part activists controversy he to be complicit through state public official in a cover-up and should also be criminally indicted.

On a warm summer Sunday in July, he was knocking top top the doors the aluminum-sided bungalows on Flint’s south Side. He looked ruddy and also cheerful; the just physical change from his appearance together Flint’s boy market were the gray streaks in his thick, wavy hair. A Flint native and a Rhodes scholar, Walling verified the same earnestness and also intellect the made him well-known as mayor, promising he would press the state to do much more to assist residents still enduring the results of tainted water.

“Part that my motivation to run was being mayor and also seeing the state not step up and do the job,” Walling said a young guy named Andre Jones. “They’ve listed water filters, yet that’s not enough. They’ve quit distributing bottled water. Now that’s gift done the end of charity contributions, yet that’s miscellaneous the state must be payment for.”

All along, Walling has actually maintained his innocence in the crisis, instead tracing that to when Michigan governor Rick Snyder stripped that of his government as mayor in 2011 and also handed it come a budget-slashing emergency manager. Walling is not among the 15 public employee who have been indicted through Michigan Attorney general Bill Schuette because that their roles in the water crisis, on charges ranging from obstructing an examination to involuntary manslaughter; the emergency manager at the moment of the crisis was indicted. This week, Walling was among a grasp of public representative dismissed from a class-action lawsuit related to the Flint crisis. (No one charged through a crime associated to the water dilemm has so far been sent out to prison, despite a few have to be sentenced come probation ~ copping plea bargains.)

Flint’s zero hangs over other races in Michigan this year. Schuette is running to replace a term-limited Snyder, and some speak he is making use of the Flint charges come “make self look like a hero,” together Susan Demas, a democratic political analyst in Michigan, placed it to me; Schuette has called such allegations “desperate.” In the democratic gubernatorial primary, ex-state councilor Gretchen Whitmer has actually released a setup to rate the replacement of command pipes, while former Detroit health and wellness director Abdul El-Sayed obtained the endorsement of “Little miss out on Flint,” the schoolgirl whose letter lugged President Barack Obama to the community.

But Walling is the only figure directly linked to the water dilemm who is seek redemption native voters. And while that hasn’t been accused that wrongdoing, that is learning that the heritage of the water situation still haunts him.

“He’s favor a character out of a shakespearean tragedy, special, Cassio come Iago in Othello,” claims Jan Worth-Nelson, editor that Flint’s East village Magazine. “Cassio is a young, inexperienced soldier Iago is an excellent at manipulating. Iago leads Cassio right into committing an action that would certainly disgrace him.”

Walling claims his very own trust in federal government is lower than it was prior to the water crisis. He currently wants to take it the tough lessons he has learned to the location he sees as the major source the Flint’s problems: the state capitol in Lansing.


When Walling moved residence to Flint in 2006, at age 32, he was the prototypical promise young politician. As a student at Michigan State University, he to be awarded a Rhodes scholarship to research in England. After that, he functioned in the Washington, D.C., mayor’s office and pursued a doctorate in geography at the college of Minnesota. Deciding the his hometown required him more than he necessary a Ph.D., that left the regime “all yet dissertation.”

A year later, Walling ran for market of Flint. He shed his first race, come a vehicle dealer called Don Williamson, yet in 2009, as soon as Williamson resigned to protect against a recall because that lying around the city’s spending plan deficit, Walling winner the one-of-a-kind election to change him, promising “to transform Flint into a sustainable 21st-century city with brand-new jobs, for sure neighborhoods, great schools and also opportunity for all,” as he when put it.

Walling might hardly have become mayor at a more complicated moment in Flint’s often-difficult history. The great Recession had actually driven the auto industry, quiet a mainstay that Flint’s economy, right into near-bankruptcy. (General motors was founded in Flint and, together late together the 1970s, still employed 80,000 workers there; it currently employs around 6,500.) between that and also the real estate crisis, building values fell an ext than 40 percent and also with them property tax receipts. In early on 2010, after ~ the police union refused to expropriate pay cuts, Walling laid off 57 officers—a third of the force. That fall, the laid turn off 20 more. By the moment Walling was finished cutting, Flint, with some 100,000 residents, was sometimes able to put only six officers on the street at one time. Murders enhanced from 36 in 2009 come a record-breaking 66 the following year, once Flint had actually the nation’s highest possible murder rate.

Nonetheless, Walling was reelected in 2011, ~ above the promise that the state—whose branch is legally permitted to piece authority indigenous mayors and councils in financially distressed cities—would not impose another emergency manager top top Flint, as had actually happened in 2002. “You’ve seen what’s occurred to this neighborhood when the spending goes wrong and we lose regulate of our whole community and also the entire autonomous process,” Walling stated at a debate that year. “That’s no going to take place while I’m her mayor.”

Yet top top the work of the election, i m sorry Walling won v 56 percent that the vote, Snyder, the Republican governor, announced he to be appointing one emergency manager to take end Flint’s finances and also attempt to get rid of its $10 million general money deficit. Walling’s salary to be cut practically in half, and his duties were decreased to clerical matters such as economic breakthrough planning and also addressing citizens’ complaints.

Before the emergency administrate appointment, the Flint City Council had endorsed a arrangement to detach the city native the Detroit water system, which it felt was charging excessive rates, and also join the new Karegnondi Water Authority, i m sorry planned to develop a pipeline indigenous Lake Huron. Emergency Manager Ed Kurtz authorized an design study to prepare the city’s water therapy plant to process Flint river water instead, and also one the Kurtz’s successors, Darnell Earley, implemented the changeover. Earley has actually been charged with false pretenses, conspiracy, willful neglect of duty, misconduct in office and also involuntary manslaughter, and also maintains his innocence; he has an upcoming hearing on respectable 13. In a 2015 Detroit News op-ed, he contended that Walling and the city council had determined to draw from the Flint River until the brand-new pipeline was completed, and also that he was only executing your orders. Kurtz, who has not to be charged, told a congressional committee investigate the water dilemm that his project was “strictly finance” and also “did not incorporate ensuring for sure drinking water.”

Walling insists that Kurtz and also Earley to be responsible for an altering the water source. “These very same decisions would certainly not have been made by city council,” he said in his very own congressional testimony, in 2016. “When the administrate decisions became known, i expressed my concerns internally around the switch, consisting of the community’s late of the river as polluted, the quick timeline to attain such a crucial change … and also the minimal staff capacity and also inexperience that Department of windy Works’ leadership had actually with to run a full time water therapy plant.” Walling says that if he had actually been allowed to practice his complete powers, he never ever would have switched the city’s drink water supply. “That was never component of mine plan,” the told me. “The gaue won projections all verified the city remaining with Detroit until the Karegnondi Water authority started.”


The notorious button-pushing photograph op to be intended to celebrate the truth that the public works department had actually won the state’s approval to move to the brand-new water supply. Fatally, though, the state had failed to require corrosion control for the flow water, i beg your pardon is harsher and also harder come treat 보다 lake water. At the time, Walling assumed of it together “a significant milestone.” Now, that calls that “a disastrous marker.”


Since his defeat, Walling has been functioning as a public policy consultant because that Michigan State University and also others, and he has had actually time come think around the changes he wants to watch in the relationship between Flint and Michigan’s state government.

“The distress of Michigan’s cities, beginning with Detroit and Flint, is a direct an outcome of policies made in Lansing,” Walling claimed in one interview at good Beans, a Flint coffee shop. “The only great news is that policy alters at the state level can aid restore Michigan’s once-great cities.”

According to a Michigan State university study, Michigan has the second-most stringent local taxation boundaries in the country, put “tremendous pressure on neighborhood lawmakers’ capacity to generate vital revenue.” On optimal of that, together Michigan’s financial fortunes began declining in the at an early stage 2000s, the state started diverting revenue-sharing money earmarked for urban to cover its own budget shortfalls. Flint lost out top top $54 million. Detroit shed $200 million, contributing come its 2013 bankruptcy, and the succeeding appointment that its very own emergency manager. Michigan has placed nine urban under emergency management, more than any other state.

On a notepad clipped inside a animal leather binder, Walling has a perform of the brand-new policies he wants to enact as a state representative. Permit cities to charge commuters the same income tax rate as residents, instead of just half. Expand the sales tax—the resource of revenue-sharing to cities—to services. Show off the state in meeting retiree costs. Right now, Flint’s residents are paying the pensions of employees who operated for the city as soon as it had actually 200,000 residents—many of them v high-paying GM jobs. That eats up a 4 minutes 1 of the city’s budget, follow to Walling.

To implement any type of of those ideas, Walling very first has come get chosen to the Legislature—when his harshest movie critics say he should be held criminally liable because that his duty in the water crisis. “Not just indicted, the should have life in prison for the human being who died from Legionella,” states water activist Arthur Woodson. “He didn’t fight for Flint. Civilization were gift poisoned, and also he to be saying ‘The water’s fine.’ human being coming in through discolored water, their hair falling out. If I deserve to see it, and also I’m not privy to all the details he deserve to get, that tells you he is lying.” as soon as Woodson found out Walling was holding a meet-and-greet in ~ a bar in the Flint suburb that Flushing, that stood exterior with a authorize reading, “DO no VOTE DAYNE.”

Walling’s critics say that also if he lacked the complete powers that his office, he to be still Flint’s just citywide chosen official, which provided him v a media platform and also a connection to state and federal officials; he could have offered both to alert the civilization to the water crisis. (In January 2015, in solution to residents’ complaints, Walling walk ask Snyder because that $20 million to improve water treatment; he gained $2 million.) some who identify Walling’s command the public policy still think he displayed a absence of leadership and also political savvy. “ wasn’t rather ready for the rough-and-tumble national politics that the situation required,” says East town Magazine’s Worth-Nelson. “He’s no bloodthirsty; he’s no ruthless.”

By Walling’s own admission, throughout most of the crisis, he believed assurances from the environmental Protection company and the Michigan room of eco-friendly Quality the Flint’s water met for sure drinking standards. (Several MDEQ employees are dealing with criminal charges because that lying that Flint’s water plant to be employing enough corrosion controls, and also for transforming water high quality reports come falsely reduced lead levels.) once residents faced him v discolored, foul-smelling water, “I thought that water had actually come the end of their tap because of a failure in the device at their home or near the house,” Walling says. In ~ his house, he says, “we just occasionally had actually discolored water that would certainly flush out once it was operation for a few minutes.” This is not precisely exculpatory: Walling resides in college Cultural, a community of handsome brick Tudors where water circulates much more rapidly and also therefore has fewer impurities than in the poor, desolate phibìc End.

Not until September 2015, ~ listening to Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha define her exploration that Flint youngsters were reflecting elevated level of command in their blood, did Walling pertained to understand that the entire water device was tainted, that says. The week, that ordered the city to issue a command advisory, advising mothers not to mix hot tap water through formula, and for all inhabitants to filter their water and flush it for 5 minutes. In her recent memoir, What the eyes Don’t See, Hanna-Attisha devotes whole chapter to her meeting v Walling, criticizing him for opting out of joining her news conference on lead levels due to the fact that he was an ext concerned around traveling come Washington to accomplish Pope Francis.

“I thought that the doctors would be the most kind the credible and also effective advocates based on the work she had done, and also the city’s task was to do what it can with the water system,” Walling claims now. “Politically, i look earlier on that, and I think, I have to have gone to the push conference, yet in my mind, i was supportive of her work.”

In her book, Hanna-Attisha concludes, “I have often suspected the if had actually been ~ above the ideal side that the fight—and had skipped his chance to fulfill the pope—things would have been different. Today, he frequently expresses regret around his role.”

Oh, yes, Walling expresses regret. He will tell friend he think “every day” about how he desire he had performed himself differently—by authorized the City the supervisory board in calling because that a go back to Detroit’s water system, or refusing come drink the water on TV and acknowledging residents’ “legitimate concerns.”

Woulda, coulda, shoulda is the lament of shedding horseplayers. Climate they turn the web page and try to win the following race. Walling’s campaign flyers don’t mention the water crisis. “My top priorities are roads, schools, jobs,” they declare. Together he walk door come door, he finds factor to hope that the voter will offer him a second chance. Throughout his critical mayoral election, the edge of Flint the lies in his would-be legislative district—the wealthiest part of the city, containing the downtown, through its brand new farmers’ market, the neighborhood University the Michigan campus, libraries, art galleries, museums and streets curving previous stately homes with lush, large lawns—gave him much more than 60 percent the the vote against his opponent, Karen Weaver. That says most voters that interacts through want to talk around the shabby state the Michigan’s roadways or the extreme auto insurance prices paid by inhabitants of Flint and also Detroit.

“Dayne demands to be connected in politics,” says Flint residents Shannon Taylor, that encountered Walling at an excellent Beans. “The failure was in state government, period: not utilizing an additive to avoid corrosion, and also not believing civilization who had troubles with their water.”

Flint’s famous congressman, Dan Kildee, has endorsed Walling’s key opponent, man Cherry III, the scion that a influential local politics family. Cherry, a Flint resident, said me that Walling’s performance throughout the water situation as “not sufficient.” Cherry’s wife became pregnant throughout the crisis. ~ his daughter to be born, his pediatrician argued a lead test, which required holding the girl down while the doctor discovered a vein. The test came earlier negative, make Cherry grateful to the doctors, scientists and activists who had actually uncovered the reality that the water to be tainted, enabling his household to take it precautions, that says.

See more: Is Olivia Newton John Still Alive, Olivia Newton

One thing Walling and also Cherry agree top top is that the emergency manager legislation is eventually to blame because that the water crisis; Cherry, too, guarantees to repeal that in Lansing if elected. As journalist Anna Clark notes in The Poisoned City, her new background of the water crisis, “The idea that emergency management is the an external official who is not constrained by regional politics or the prospect of a reelection bid will be able to far better make the complicated decisions essential to obtain a struggling city or college district back on heavy ground.” but in Flint, emergency supervisors made decisions based upon saving money, no the health and safety that the citizens v whose well-being they had been entrusted.

“I wish that I had never been component of any kind of of it,” Walling says currently of the water crisis. “This has actually all occurred to a community that ns deeply love, and it is inspiring me come make sure policy changes are made come make sure this never ever happens again.”