Children entrusted come state care after they room abused or neglected by your parents space bouncing in between hotels and also other emergency housing, and also even gift shipped the end of Washington with growing frequency, victim of a major shortage of foster homes.

You are watching: Is the foster care system overpopulated

More than a decade after the court ordered the state to reduce excessive moves amongst foster kids, part still find themselves uprooted dozens of time in a matter of months.

This instability ultimately expenses taxpayers. It increases foster children’s usage of mental health services. As adults, foster children are an ext likely to it is in jailed, have actually unintended pregnancies, abuse drugs and be unemployed. Professionals say the extreme rootlessness experienced by some renders them more likely to loss victim to those perils.

An investigation by InvestigateWest for KCTS 9 and Crosscut reflects an uptick in foster kids who relocate so often, because that so long, that they have become what professionals dub “homeless in foster care.”

“We have actually a huge billboard by our residence saying, ‘Make a shelter pet part of your world.’ yet there’s nothing the says, ‘Become a foster parent, since otherwise these children are safety 24 hours at a location desk, i m sorry is no way to treat them.’”—Lauren Hubbard, a foster mom in Seattle

“It’s just inflicting an ext trauma to several of the most breakable youth,” stated Patrick Dowd, the state main in charge of investigating complaints about the foster-care system.

The investigation consisted of a review of state records and dozens of interviews v social workers, foster parents and also others involved in the foster care system.

In an internal email acquired by InvestigateWest, the administrator in fee of the state’s Puget Sound-area foster-care system in July defined the situation as a “crisis.”


With no location else to take the foster children, society workers have increasingly resorted to housing youngsters in many hotels at night, climate babysitting castle in state boy welfare offices during the day. In June alone, foster children as young together 2 had 211 hotel continues to be — more than any kind of other month since the state child welfare ombudsman started receiving complaints about the exercise two years ago.

The state has grown for this reason desperate that it pays part foster parents up to $325 a night, an ext than 10 times the usual everyday rate, to board youngsters from bedtime until morning. It stashes other children in team facilities because that runaways and youths with significant mental health problems, not because they need such nearby monitoring, but since there room no constant foster households to take it them.

This can include up to 10, 20, also 50 moves in a matter of month — for young children as well as unruly teens. Earlier this year, because that example, a 4-year-old was moved in between 10 various families over 3 months and likewise spent several nights in hotels, according to records acquired by InvestigateWest.

With each move, kids’ actions often worsens, making that harder to discover a foster household — or even a group facility — maybe to attend to them. Numerous eventually flee come the streets, whereby they are more likely come be victim of sex trafficking and violence.

“If we execute not care for these children appropriately, us know, unfortunately, that they climate move right into homelessness, right into our juvenile justice and other public care systems,” stated Bill Grimm, a lawyer with the National center for Youth Law. “So they include to the price that we then have for taking care of them down the road.”

Evidence that such harm to foster children helped Grimm and other advocates win a 2004 settlement requiring the Washington room of Social and also Health services to give foster kids an ext stability. Once the state met that goal, though, court monitoring of move stopped. And moves are boosting again, follow to state records, social workers and also foster parents themselves.


Angelique Kelley, Lauren Hubbard and Reiley Wicken. Picture by Paul Joseph Brown/

Over the past year, “We would get emails with 20 kids on them, saying it’s a crisis, we require placements, aid us,” claimed Seattle foster mommy Lauren Hubbard, who embraced her daughter Angelique Kelley, 15, the end of foster care.

In 3 years in foster care, Angelique moved 17 time — an typical of once every two months. The took ha weeks to convince her to unpack her suitcase.

As with plenty of foster kids, those moves left Angelique struggling in school. With all of her college changes, no one had actually stopped to number out she had actually dyslexia. “I just felt stupid,” she said. She still four or 5 years behind.

Amid every those moves, Angelique says, her heart “broke into 17 pieces.”

A significant driver the the placement dilemm is a large decrease in the number of available foster homes, a topic fine cover in a forthcoming story. When the state for decades had about 6,000 foster homes, over the critical eight years the number has dropped to about 5,000.

At the same time, the variety of kids eliminated from their houses has raised in the past couple of years, after falling during the recession, likely due in component to skyrocketing rates of heroin and also prescription opioid addiction. Neglect due to parents’ drug addiction is a usual reason for kids coming right into the system. Various other youths have been abused physical or sexually, or otherwise severely mistreated by your parents or guardians.

Beyond recruiting more foster parents, longtime observers say brand-new approaches are needed to treatment for the growing number of foster youngsters with severe psychological health and behavioral troubles.

“The an ext we get involved, the an ext we realize simply how damaged the device is,” claimed Dan Hamer, one associate minister at Overlake Christian Church in Redmond that oversees support services for foster and adoptive families and has additionally taken in foster kids himself.

“We can’t simply keep repeating the same thing, and think, oh, we just need more, better recruitment, far better retention” of foster parents, Hamer said. “You’re not going to acquire that until you readjust some the the fundamental problems in ~ the system.”


“We hold human being accountable to sex abuse, to physics abuse, to all these different kinds of abuse, due to the fact that the regulations protect kids from them. Why can’t we protect kids from the abuse of excessive moves? Of breaks in attachment? the the trauma that too plenty of moves? that seems favor we should be able to do that.” —Michele Schneidler, foster and also adoptive mom, and pastor because that orphan care at Overlake Christian Church in Redmond.

Some of the many promising fixes encompass training and paying highly expert foster parents, expanding mental health services for the many troubled kids and also paying knowledgeable social workers sufficient to keep them around. Yet these services all expense money that would have to come native the Washington Legislature.

Meanwhile, the Legislature has actually yet to fully restore the steep recession-era budget cuts that trimmed more than 15 percent the Children’s management workers, froze society workers’ salaries, and slashed services for foster children and also parents.

The DSHS administrator in fee of the foster treatment system acknowledges the the agency, even if that were correctly funded, needs to expand options beyond traditional foster families.

“We, like numerous child welfare systems, have clung to the foster care model and, correctly or wrongly, have actually used that as a solution,” said Jennifer Strus, the DSHS assistant secretary who heads the children Administration. “We’re a reactive agency, simply by the nature the what us do, and also I don’t think that we more than likely were looking ahead as lot as we most likely should have.”

“But we’re absolutely doing the now.”

For foster kids, the transforms can’t come quickly enough.

Emergent help needed!

In June and also July, social workers in DSHS region 2, extending Western Washington indigenous King county north, received a cable of emails from supervisors with topic lines such as “Placement crisis in the region” and also “Emergent aid needed!” The local administrator wrote of “a placement dilemm that continues to worsen” and also warned that mandatory overtime for hotel stays would be compelled if no enough human being volunteered.

The summer’s surging in hotel usage signals how urgent the foster household shortage has become.

Department plan prohibits keeping kids overnight in DSHS workplaces — a common practice in past years — or in “an college not set up to get foster children.” But firm managers can grant “placement exceptions” for kids to continue to be in a hotel, office or apartment.

“You lose a little piece of yourself every time you walk to a various family. It’s difficult to have faith in the civilization when the things the adults are telling you don’t pan out, or you’re never able to uncover a permanent family”.—Adam Cornell, previous foster child and also Snohomish ar prosecutor

The number of nights children stayed in many hotels increased much more than seven-fold end the last year. In the past 12 month there to be 883 location exceptions involving 221 children, compared to just 120 exceptions entailing 72 youngsters in the previous year, follow to the state Office of Family and Children’s Ombuds, which handles complaints around the foster treatment system. Nearly all arisen in region 2 critical year, through 57 percent in King County. Practically all to be hotel stays, yet in a few cases kids likewise stayed in DSHS offices.

In enhancement to the expense of the hotel room, the state need to pay two social workers, and also sometimes a defense guard, who stay awake all night supervising the children.

Teens space most most likely to finish up in hotels, however children together young as 2 have recently invested nights there. Three-quarters that the kids placed in hotels last year were period 12 and also older, and a disproportionate number were youngsters of color, the Ombuds office reported. Numerous have far-ranging mental wellness needs or a background of to run away, aggressive behavior, or utilizing drugs or alcohol.

Those troubled youngsters are difficult to location in any type of foster home, Strus of DSHS says.

InvestigateWest learned of one teen who freshly spent 38 consecutive nights in hotels. Others have spent 2 or three weeks in hotels, regularly interspersed with one-night foster-home stays.

Child advocates speak to the practice unacceptable.

“These are youth that more than likely are in biggest need the stability… and also yet these room the ones that don’t know where they room going come be resting the following night,” stated Dowd, the state ombudsman.

Hotels are the alternative of critical resort. One step below that space a grasp of high-priced foster dwellings that agree come put youngsters up for one night in ~ a time for everyday fees ranging from $40 come $325. Those amounts can be on height the $100 every night payment to part so-called receiving homes that take children when they first come into care. Standard reimbursement prices for most foster parents begin at around $18 a day.

DSHS claimed such high fees are frequently authorized for kids or youth with really high needs.

These night-by-night foster parents regularly require social workers to drop the children off ~ 7 p.m. And to choose them increase as beforehand as 6:30 in the morning. With no one to drive them come school, these children typically invest the next day sitting in a DSHS office.

“The youth is not getting any sort of hopeful relationship or nurturing native a caregiver,” Dowd said. “And what kind of article does that provide the youth as much as their very own value?”

Several social workers claimed using such night-by-night foster homes is not new, but that the fees they demand have crept up steadily.

“They kind of host the room hostage, which is a dreadful thing to say,” said Tanya Copenhaver, a social worker through the Children’s management for 15 years who left a year ago for a better-paying task in healthcare. “But you have to place the kid somewhere, for this reason you have to pay the money.”

Strus denied that the case is markedly worse than in the past. “To explain this as a placement crisis that is new to us would not be accurate,” she said. “We have always probably had a need for an ext foster parents 보다 we usually have. The children have gotten much more difficult… and also it’s challenging to find civilization who are willing to take it these children on v their many issues.”

A new six-bed facility that opened up in July in Seattle has helped ease the immediate crisis, Strus said. In August, hotel continues to be dropped come 25. This fall, one more 20 bed for teenagers will come to be available.

But long-term, two dozen beds are not walk to solve the crisis.

More moves, much more troubles

After household turmoil left him homeless at age 13, Ronnie Andrews states he moved practically 50 time in 5 years, mostly between short-term group facilities.

Andrews, now 18, remembers one of the many times his society worker came to move him. They loaded his few possessions right into her car. “I looked in the back, and I just seen every my stuff in plastic bags, and I just started crying,” andrews said.

“I cry ‘cause that how bad it was to sit there and look at that … and how countless times I’ve had to take it my stuff the end of those bags, and also like a main or 2 weeks later, having to placed them right back in there.”

Andrews’ story is similar to the of the dozen foster children who filed the Braam v. State the Washington class activity lawsuit, which was cleared up in 2004. The referee agreed that youngsters had been harmed by extreme moves and also unsafe placements, consisting of stays in DSHS offices and detention centers.

“The parental have way too many rights, when they’re the ones who placed the boy in this instance in the first place. Lock told me that constitutional ideal to be a parent, and we can not take the away. Friend don’t have to be a great parent, lock told me, the not against the law to it is in a bad parent. As soon as are we going come worry about what’s finest for the child? that the parents who have actually all the laws.” —Brandon Fogg, 24, that spent around six year in foster care, till he was adopted. As an adult, he promoted his baby brother for 2 years in the expect of adopting him, before a judge reverted him to their mother in June

Under an independent monitor, moves amongst foster kids fell steadily through 2011, when the state met agreed-upon benchmarks and also court scrutiny ceased. Yet the number of moves appears to it is in creeping increase again. Southwestern Washington, in particular, has seen a sharp spike in moves, with prices that space one and also a half times the state as a whole.

Between 2012 and also 2014, the percent of children with three or more moves in the very first year of care rose to 19 percent indigenous 15 percent, according to a DSHS report to the commonwealth government. The commonwealth standard states no much more than 14 percent of children should have that plenty of moves.

These averages conceal the stories of many kids who still suffer dozens of moves.

Among plenty of other examples recorded by InvestigateWest in the past year:

A 7-year-old had actually 18 placements over about two months, including 10 different foster homes, add to time in team homes and hotels.A 3-year-old that was initially placed in a short-term sanctuary laid his head at five foster houses within 2 months.Over a two-week period, a 5-year-old to be shuffled between six homes and also spent number of nights in hotels.A 14-year-old spent 40 nights in hotels and also one-night foster homes before the state found a household that would keep him much longer — for a fee of $200 a night.

These youngsters represent a small portion of the approximately 9,000 youngsters in foster care in Washington together of this summer. But social workers say the it has end up being increasingly an overwhelming to find any family — let alone a family matched come a child’s demands — also for the youngest children in need.

In the past, veteran society worker Copenhaver says, she had actually some ability to be responsibility of a child’s social and behavior needs in order to discover a residence that might last. “But you not able to perform that now, because we just need to place them where there is a bed available, and a foster parent who’s willing. … and also that leaves kids bouncing from residence to home to home.”


Many children living top top the street space “refugees from foster care.” “Once you’ve been through 10, 12 placements, you’re traumatized, and then every placement is a trigger, and also nowhere is safe. So then you fail in every one of the next placements, because you’re set up for failure. For this reason by the moment they’re 15, 16, 17, they’re prefer done, and also they go the streets. And also that’s whereby I fulfill them.” —Kathleen Hamer works with homeless youngsters as a youth outreach counselor at Overlake Christian Church in Redmond.

Even once a house is available, many foster parents room not ready or trained to take emotionally troubled children. At least fifty percent of foster youngsters have severe mental health or behavioral problems, research studies show. And also when “the inevitable explosion with these youngsters happens, yes sir no support” native the state, stated Hamer, the Overlake Christian Church pastor. “So it’s location number 19, placement number 20.”

When foster children are shuffled in between homes, trusting and also attaching come anyone i do not care harder and also harder, experts and also the children themselves say.

The an ext children room moved, “the less likely it is the they’re going to make an emotional commitment or invest in the next home,” said Dee Wilson, that led a study institute in ~ the university of Washington school of Social occupational after 26 year of business at the children Administration. “So you can end up getting youngsters who room very, really hard to find them a household at every after a while, since they have a deep distrust of adult that’s based on some really good reasons.”

Ronnie andrew remembers how he felt an ext detached through each move.

“I would sit there when I an initial moved right into a place,” andrew says, “and I’m like, ‘Do I also want to build a relationship? carry out I even want to shot in this place? ‘Cause exactly how long am I even going to stay right here for?’”

Like many long-term foster children, andrews turned 18 without being adopted or finding a legit guardian.

More than half of youth who age out of treatment without ever getting a permanent residence were in foster care for 3 or much more years, according to DSHS’s 2016 progress report come the federal government. Youngsters of shade tend to stay in foster treatment longer and also to experience greater instability than white kids, the report says.

Children who get in foster care with behavioral problems, no surprisingly, space harder come stabilize. Yet studies show that even youngsters who don’t start out with troubles are much more likely to build them when they are moved around.

Young children, in particular, space harmed by instability. For kids under 3, every additional move has actually been attached to an ext behavior problems. Because that older kids, unplanned moves — usually since the foster parents can not cope through the child’s actions — have the most an adverse impacts, Wilson said: “It typically is regarded by the children as rejection, i beg your pardon a lot of times it is.”

Tougher kids, fewer resources

 Foster children are coming into treatment with more problems than ever, specialists agree. It is due in part to the state’s success at keeping children with their families by offering voluntary services, meaning the kids who finish up gaining removed are the ones because that whom those initiatives haven’t been successful. “So friend inherently acquire more an overwhelming children,” Copenhaver said.

At the exact same time, sources to treatment for together children, including residential facilities and specially trained “treatment” or “therapeutic” foster families, to be slashed throughout the economic downturn.

Concerns around the quality of care in team homes and also high-profile abuse scandals at some facilities, such as the previous O.K. Guys Ranch in Olympia, likewise spurred efforts to shutter countless group houses in current decades. Currently some speak the state needs to turning back course and also expand group-care options. But they also caution that youngsters should not be warehoused in such facilities for extended periods.

State Rep. Ruth Kagi, a Seattle Democrat who chairs the House beforehand Learning and Human services Committee, agrees that the state must boost capacity in team homes. “But by far the best alternate is to build therapeutic foster homes, wherein foster parents room well-trained on just how to regulate these behaviors,” Kagi said. She has likewise asked the room to report by November on what’s essential to resolve the location crisis and how much it’s most likely to cost.

To avoid placing kids in group facilities, DSHS is considering broadening the use of so-called “staffed residential” foster homes, wherein foster parenting is a full time job, according to Strus.

But even if the department it s okay programs favor this running, “the thing that throw a wrench right into that is … the Legislature cuts your funds, and also then you can not sustain what you’ve built,” Strus said.

In February, Gov. Jay Inslee convened a the supervisory board to advice the production of a stand-alone children Administration. The group’s report come the branch is early out Nov. 1.

See more: Is Maxine Waters Up For Reelection In 2018, Elections 2018: Rep

Kagi, who co-chairs the commission, supplied to oppose spinning off the children’s Administration. Now she thinks it can lead to a stronger, more coordinated emphasis on kid welfare. “We require to have actually a department where that room head speak to the governor directly … and where children are simply a emphasis of a department,” she said.

Others doubt the such a restructuring have the right to undo years of inconsistent and inadequate funding. “The Legislature has just practically, by your mismanagement… condemned the state mechanism to mediocrity,” Wilson said. “The idea the somehow there’s part cost-neutral method of resolving this, fine that’s simply not true.”