Share every sharing alternatives for: Stat check: No, ladies couldn’t just “go what else” if planned Parenthood closed

Olivier Douliery/Getty photos
The "defund planned Parenthood" movement has actually a standard response to the inquiry of where women would certainly go if their neighborhood clinic closed: what else.

You are watching: Is planned parenthood the only place that does abortions

"There space 13,000 community-based establishments that administer health services to women, 13,000 in this country," Jeb shrub said at an early Republican major debate. "I don’t believe that to plan Parenthood should obtain a penny from the commonwealth government."

Other Republicans do a similar claim. A spokesperson because that Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) said that to plan Parenthood"s resources could be sail to "community health and wellness centers and other entities giving health solutions without abortions." and also on paper, it sounds plausible the 13,000 clinics might have the ability to absorb planned Parenthood"s 2.7 million patients who gain government aid paying because that birth control and other reproductive wellness services.

But as the Senate votes to piece Planned Parenthood the millions in commonwealth funding, a testimonial of scholastic research, recent Planned Parenthood closures in Texas, and also interviews with fifty percent a dozen wellness policy experts suggests the opposite. Historically, researcher have uncovered that once Planned Parenthood clinics close, various other clinics carry out not step up to to fill the gap. Meanwhile, when there are fewer reproductive wellness clinics available, women get less reproductive health treatment — indigenous birth control to cancer screenings come STD testing and treatment. Unintended pregnancies would most likely increase, too.

When to plan Parenthood clinics close, other providers don"t action up

So while numerous politicians prefer to assert that women can "go what else," the consensus in the literature shows a various picture. Higher-income women will find alternatives. However a sizable decimal of planned Parenthood"s patients, an especially low-income women, would lose accessibility to medical services.

Planned Parenthood is a major part that America"s reproductive health network

Melina Mara/The Washington article via Getty images

A patient has actually a Pap smear check at a Texas plan Parenthood. (Melina Mara/the Washington article via Getty Images)

Planned Parenthood theatre a large role in women"s reproductive health treatment in America for two reasons: It has actually hundreds that clinics, and also those clinics often tend to serve a higher number of patient than other health-care providers.

About one in six American counties — 491 counties in complete — have a to plan Parenthood clinic. Taken together, they see about 2.6 million patients annually.

Planned Parenthood exist in many places where other family members planning clinics don"t: A new analysis from the Guttmacher Institute approximates that there are 103 counties in the United says where planned Parenthood is the only provider that publicly sponsor contraceptives. In second 229 counties, plan Parenthood offer the majority of women who room low-income and also qualify for government assist paying for birth control.

(Guttmacher Institute/Health Affairs)

This relates to the other essential fact to know around Planned Parenthood: It often tends to serve way more females in public programs 보다 do other places, prefer public wellness clinics or primary care doctors. Castle see, top top average, 2,950 birth regulate patients per year, contrasted with the mean of 750 watched at public health centers and 330 at commonwealth qualified health centers.

To put it an additional way: to plan Parenthood clinics comprise only 10 percent of publicly sponsor contraceptive clinics — however see 36 percent of patient who usage the government birth regulate programs. Your clinics have occurred a specialty in this area, and also are particularly tailored toward offering reproductive wellness care. The various other clinics that view fewer birth manage patients, however, don"t have that specialty — and experts to speak they"d struggle to absorb added patients.

"One of the disagreements that has come up at conference hearings is the you could take the money we spend on planned Parenthood and push that to community health centers," states Kinsey Hasstedt, a public plan associate at the Guttmacher Institute, which supports abortion rights. "But through the fact of the caseload, and with countless patients, we can"t count on community health centers to pick up the slack."

Texas reduced Planned Parenthood out of its family members planning networks — and women obtained less wellness care


A group from Texas screens flags throughout a rally top top the Mall because that the March for Life anti-abortion demonstration. (Photo by Tom Williams/CQ roll Call)

Texas has actually for years now been a battleground because that women"s health. That abortion constraints are at this time being challenged before the can be fried Court — and also its own, successful work to defund planned Parenthood has correlated with females receiving much less reproductive health care in public programs.

In 2013, the Texas Women"s wellness Program began excluding planned Parenthood native its network that clinics wherein low-income women might get contraceptives, STD screenings, and also other reproductive wellness services. The Women"s health and wellness Program never ever paid for abortions.

"When Texas defunded planned Parenthood, there to be a most talk that it will be basic to to fill the gaps and no one would shed services," says Leighton Ku, a public health and wellness researcher at George Washington University. "We referred to as other clinics and asked them, "If to plan Parenthood couldn"t do this anymore, room you prepared to step up to the plate?" The answer, in the quick run, to be they couldn"t perform it. They just had minimal capacity."

Since Texas defunded planned Parenthood, under women get reproductive care

State data shows that there is no Planned Parenthood in the network, the public program detailed care to about 9 percent fewer females than that did in 2011. In the West Texas region, women offered by the program declined by 40 percent between 2011 and 2013 — the exact same year the Planned Parenthood closed 2 clinics in that area that the state.

"You had actually a provider shortage," claims Joe Potter, a researcher that runs college of Texas"s plan Evaluation Project. As component of the project, Potter has functioned with his colleague Dr. Junda Woo to study what happened to women watched at planned Parenthood clinics in 2 Texas cities. That work, i m sorry is at this time under scholastic review, reflects that some individuals of injectable contraceptive (Depo Provera) to be unable to discover an alternative provider to proceed with the shots quickly after Texas cut Planned Parenthood clinics out of network.

"There were barriers, Potter says. "Not everybody uncovered a brand-new provider, some who did had actually to salary copays or undergo new sets that exams. Those who went back to to plan Parenthood after ~ the exclusion had to salary somewhere between $60 and also $100 because that their following shots."

Data from the Texas wellness Department the State health and wellness Services says that cut Planned Parenthood out of the Women"s health Program may have actually helped mitigate abortions in Texas. Elective abortion procedures fell 6.5 percent between 2012 and also 2013 (abortions likewise fell 6 percent in between 2011 and 2012, prior to Planned Parenthood lost funding, so it"s tough to know whether the later decline is a product of the regulation or reflects a national decrease in abortion rates).

It is feasible that cutting off Planned Parenthood"s government resources can alleviate abortions – and that in the process, accessibility to household planning services will be a casualty.

David Slusky, an economist at the college of Kansas, has studied the closure of family planning clinics in both Texas and Wisconsin, whereby Gov. Scott Walker reduced reproductive health and wellness funds in a means that disproportionately influenced abortion clinics choose Planned Parenthood.

His work, published with college of Chicago"s Yao Lu in the newspaper of used Economics, isn"t about Planned Parenthood specifically. The looks in ~ an anonymous, national network of household planning clinics. Still, the findings are the same: when clinics close, no all women find a new provider. Part just gain less care.

More special, Slusky and also Lu show that increasing a patient"s street to a family planning clinic by 100 miles leader to one 11 percent decrease in clinical breast exams and also a 14 percent autumn in Pap smears. Decreases in care were even bigger amongst lower-income and less-educated women.

"Preventive care is all about reducing future injury to yourself," Slusky says. "So if you can"t take off job-related to journey 100 miles every way, then you"re not going come go, due to the fact that it"s no worth it. When access to care is such an issue, that could be a totally rational decision for even a forward-looking person."

If plan Parenthood shutters, others fear a comparable outcome

The Congressional spending plan Office recently surveyed the existing literary works on planned Parenthood and estimated that if conference did defund the group, somewhere in between 5 and also 25 percent the its clients — 130,000 come 630,000 ladies — would lose access to care.

What"s more: CBO approximated in a separate report the defunding planned Parenthood would price the federal government $130 million over a decade, since it would certainly reduce accessibility to family planning services and also increase unintended pregnancies.

There are some clinics the say they might step up to fill the gap Planned Parenthood would leave behind. The national Review recently pointed come Obria, a medical clinic the presents itself together a planned Parenthood alternative, as one together example.

"These clinics and maternity dwellings have enormous power that persuasion in the abortion conflict — simply since they exist," Erika Bachiochi created in that article.

See more: When Is Spring Coming Early This Year 2019 ? 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024?

There are other clinics prefer Obria that exist, however they are couple of and far between. And also with to plan Parenthood serving much more than 2.6 million women who obtain publicly funded contraceptives, there just aren"t sufficient to fill the gap. That"s the allude the California Primary care Association make in a current letter come Congress.

"Eliminating plan Parenthood from our state"s considerable network of care would put untenable anxiety on the remaining providers," Andie Martinez Patterson, the group"s manager of government affairs, wrote. "We execute not have actually the capacity for such rise in care and also building together capacity would certainly require far-reaching capital investment."