A local ordinance that prohibits providing free food to more than five civilization is one infringement on totally free speech and religious liberties, the lawsuit alleges.


On a current evening in April, a couple of dozen people experiencing homelessness inside wall up outside central Library in downtown Houston for a cost-free — and also illegal — enjoy the meal of vegetarian chili, macaroni, rice and also fruit salad. Volunteers v Food no Bombs, an international organization with numerous local chapters, frequently serve cost-free dinner here, violating a local ordinance versus publicly feeding groups of world without city permission.

You are watching: Is it illegal to feed the homeless

Houston’s so-called charitable-feeding ordinance was enacted in 2012 and permits groups and also individuals to feeding up to five homeless people, no strings attached. To feeding more, though, you should register through the city — or confront fines up to $2,000 and also a misdemeanor charge for violating the Houston password of Ordinances. Additionally, would-be do-gooders need to take a food dealing with training class; provide the propose schedule, time and location the the ad-hoc soup kitchen; information the food gift served; and also fill the end an online form to obtain permission from the city to give food in public.

On Monday, activists filed a federal lawsuit seeking to overturn the ordinance on very first Amendment grounds. Food not Bombs and also three the its members are plaintiffs in the suit, filed against the City of Houston in the U.S. Southerly District the Texas. The sue accuses the city that infringing on freedom of speech and spiritual liberties that the anti-war, food-sharing activists. The asks Houston to overthrow the ban and seeks unspecified monetary damages.

The ordinance infringes ~ above “freedom of association” and also “political organizing” and is “unconstitutionally vague,” the sue argues. It cites at least 19 pro-food-sharing verses indigenous the Bible. Randall Kallinen, who has actually filed many civil rights lawsuits in Houston, is representing the activists. In interviews through the Observer, he defined the ordinance as “totally ridiculous” and part of an initiative to “get the homeless the end of town.”

While the sue adds to pressure against Houston, the initiative to overturn the city’s half is no new. A parallel lawsuit also involving Kallinen has been floundering in state ar court due to the fact that 2017, and also over 75,000 world have signed an virtual petition calling because that an end to the “cruel” ordinance.

Critics speak the procedure is onerous and also keeps volunteers from giving assistance to civilization in need. Houston public official who’ve sustained the ordinance to speak it protects the human being receiving food and doesn’t criminalize those giving it. “All us ask is that you it is in a good neighbor and coordinate” v the city, then-Mayor Annise Parker said in 2013 when an activist pressed her on the ban. “It doesn’t assist the homeless to leaving them ~ above the streets.”

“We have actually a persistent issue of homelessness that’s going unaddressed.”

Mary Benton, a spokesperson for market Sylvester Turner, claimed the city had actually not yet watched the lawsuit as soon as asked around an hour after it to be filed Monday, but pointed come the 2017 instance being dismissed. Once previously asked around that suit, Alan Bernstein, one more spokesperson because that Turner, expressed concern that “one person’s an individual religious objection come an otherwise secular law have the right to defeat the ordinance together a whole.”

According to the U.S. Department of Housing and also Urban Development, an ext than 25,000 Texans knowledgeable homelessness on any kind of given day in 2018. In the after-effects of Hurricane Harvey, the number of people there is no permanent real estate in Houston rose after years of slow-but-steady decline, from about 3,500 in 2017 to end 4,000 last year, follow to data native the Houston Coalition because that the Homeless. But such populations are notoriously tough to track and often underreported.

That’s because of the rarely often rare living cases in i beg your pardon many civilization experiencing homelessness discover themselves, in addition to the varying interpretations of what it method to be “homeless,” claimed Brett Merfish, director of youth justice in ~ the advocacy team Texas Appleseed. “I deserve to confidently to speak there’s an undercounting,” Merfish claimed of Texas homelessness counts an especially for children and also young adults. “We have actually a persistent problem of homelessness it is going unaddressed.”

*
Homeless student populaces in Texas (2017). Click to enlarge. Texas Appleseed and Texas Network for Youth Services

Life has actually long been daunting for Houston’s homeless population. The city has actually recently to be breaking up homeless encampments under freeways, most notably the one in ~ the U.S. 59 underpass in Midtown. It’s likewise fighting panhandling with the mantra “Meaningful adjust — no Spare Change.” when a panhandling ban has been ~ above the books due to the fact that 1992, authorities have actually recently ramped up efforts to avoid it, an especially in the upscale Galleria area.

The ordinance pits those who care for the homeless professionally against committed volunteers. When it was being taken into consideration by city council, a group of public-private do-gooders published an op-ed in the Houston Chronicle touting the ban as a means to do food-sharing an ext “efficient and effective … while in ~ the same time protecting building rights.”

Arguments favor these reflect an initiative by developed nonprofits to safeguard their funding, claimed Nick Cooper, a Food no Bombs member. “You have to understand, yes a somewhat symbiotic relationship between big nonprofits and also city,” he said. “There’s no question in mine mind that the legislation has had a chilling result on volunteerism.”

The Dallas skyline looms behind the homeless encampment a couple of weeks before city officials cleared it in 2016. Patrick Michels

Megan Hustings, director of the nationwide Coalition for the Homeless, watch ordinances favor Houston’s as part of a statewide and also national effort to actors people without permanent housing into the shadows. Hustings, who opposes feeding bans, has studied these concerns for over a decade and also says there is “little to no evidence” the homeless world get noble from handouts or being served tainted food.

See more: Is Arya Stark Going To Die, Will Arya Stark Die On Game Of Thrones

Kallinen, the lawyer, said his sue is a textbook spiritual freedom case. In August, the 11th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals allowed a Food not Bombs group in fort Lauderdale, Florida, to continue feeding the homeless (without explicitly overturning the city’s ban on law so) after ~ a lawsuit from the group and also four members. Because the organization “does not serve food together a charity, however rather to communicate its post ‘that society can end hunger and also poverty if we redirect our collective resources indigenous the military and war,’” the feeding tasks are “protected by the very first Amendment,” the court ruled.

Shere Dore, a Food not Bombs activist and also plaintiff, has actually been involved in legal challenges due to the fact that 2017. Friend can uncover her most nights in former of Houston main Library, giving out cost-free vegetarian meals. Police don’t stroked nerves her lot here; for a while, the city even described these Food not Bombs meals as “approved” despite members repeatedly refusing to it is registered in protest that the ordinance. But for Dore, who’s also a black Lives issue activist, the hit to legalization food-sharing is about more than bureaucracy. “I want to offer food wherever i feel prefer without having actually to worry around officers,” she said. “A the majority of other people want to serve, yet they space literally too scared to come out.”